Choosing the right creative and marketing partner is a big decision.
The work they produce shapes how your brand looks, sounds, and shows up in the market, so consistency, quality, and execution matter more than ever.
If you’re comparing MarketerHire vs Designity, you’re likely deciding between two very different models.
MarketerHire connects you with freelance marketing talent, while Designity operates as a fully managed Creative as a Service platform with dedicated Creative Directors and end-to-end project management.
In this comparison, we’ll give you a clear look at how the two stack up when it comes to pricing and value and how much hands-on management your team needs to provide.
Let’s get this show on the road.
What Is MarketerHire?
MarketerHire is a freelance platform designed to streamline the hiring process for businesses that need marketing talent.
It connects companies with pre-vetted freelance professionals who can support specific projects or ongoing marketing needs.
This model is especially helpful for teams that want to avoid the time-consuming and often unpredictable process of hiring in-house marketers or designers, as well as the challenge of managing full-time salaries when budgets shift.
Plus, it also removes the burden of sourcing, vetting, and onboarding freelancers independently.
MarketerHire’s network includes marketing specialists across a wide range of disciplines, such as digital marketing, social media, email marketing, SEO, and paid media, along with creative professionals in areas like graphic design, copywriting, web design, and video editing.
What Is Designity?
Based in New York, Designity is a fully managed Creative-as-a-Service platform built to offer brands a more flexible, scalable alternative to traditional agencies.
Instead of juggling freelancers, you get on-demand access to the top 3% of creative talent across branding, UX/UI, web design, development, and more.
Every project is fully managed and guided by a dedicated Creative Director with 10+ years of experience, who serves as your main point of contact and keeps work aligned, consistent, and moving forward.
Designity has partnered with leading brands like Marriott, Calendly, and Kung Fu Tea, helping teams of all sizes scale creative and marketing execution without the complexity, overhead, or guesswork that typically comes with managing freelancers.
A Comparison at First Glance: MarketerHire vs Designity
Here is a quick look at how these two platforms differ before diving into the details:
Now, let’s take a closer look at how these two creative platforms differ in terms of:
- Project Management
- Range of Services
- Creative Director Supervision
- Client Onboarding Process
- Creatives' Vetting Process
- Project Requests and Revisions
- Trial Period & Pricing Plans
1. Project Management
Strong creative output depends on strong project management. The biggest difference between Designity and MarketerHire is how much responsibility your team takes on once work begins:
A. MarketerHire
MarketerHire handles the initial matching process by connecting you with a vetted freelance marketer.
After that, the day-to-day execution largely falls on your team.
So, this is basically MarketerHire after they match you with a freelancer:
Just kidding.
They do check in sometimes, but you’re responsible for providing creative direction, managing timelines, reviewing work, and ensuring quality.
This model can work well for teams with the time and expertise to manage freelancers directly, but it does require more hands-on involvement to keep projects moving smoothly.
B. Designity
With Designity, every client and project is led by a dedicated Creative Director with 10+ years of experience in creative strategy, project management, team leadership, and design.
Your Creative Director serves as your single point of contact and fully manages execution from start to finish.
They oversee timelines, maintain quality standards, source and manage the right creatives for each project, and ensure everything stays aligned with your goals.
The result is a hands-off, fully managed experience where your team focuses on outcomes, not coordination.
2. Range of Services
Now, let’s see if the services each platform offers match your specific project needs:
A. MarketerHire
MarketerHire is built around individual marketing roles, not full creative and marketing coverage.
You’re essentially hiring one freelancer at a time, usually focused on a single channel like paid media, email, SEO, or social.
Yes, some creative work is possible, like ad design or basic motion graphics, depending on who you’re matched with. But the scope is limited to that person’s skill set.
If you suddenly need landing pages, brand work, video, or anything outside their lane, you’re back to sourcing another freelancer or vendor.
MarketerHire works if you need one very specific thing and are comfortable managing the rest yourself.
It’s not built for teams that want end-to-end creative and marketing support without juggling people (and headaches).
B. Designity
Designity takes the opposite approach. Instead of locking you into one role, you get access to 100+ creative and marketing services across every plan.
Marketing strategy, motion graphics and animation, web design and development, video, content, SEO, email campaigns, packaging… you name it, it’s handled.
But the biggest difference?
How we deliver those services.
Everything runs through a dedicated Creative Director who manages the work, pulls in the right creatives, and keeps it all aligned.
You’re not guessing who to hire next or stitching work together after the fact.
Need to scale up?
Add more creatives to your plan in seconds right from the Designity client portal.
3. Creative Director Supervision
Creative Director (CD) supervision keeps your projects aligned, on-brand, and moving in the right direction.
Let’s compare how MarketerHire and Designity handle it:
A. MarketerHire
MarketerHire doesn’t include Creative Director or strategic oversight by default.
At $5,000 per month, you’re matched with a junior or mid-level marketer focused on a single channel, while creative direction, quality control, and brand alignment sit with your team.
If you want senior guidance, like a fractional CMO or creative strategist, you’ll need to hire that role separately at a much higher cost, often around $15,000 per month.
It works well if you already have strong direction in-house. If not, things can start to feel a little… directionally challenged.
B. Designity
With Designity, every client gets a dedicated Creative Director, included on every plan.
Your Creative Director is a hands-on partner who shapes creative direction, manages timelines, oversees quality, and leads communication through weekly check-ins.
They also hand-pick and manage the right creatives for each project, removing the need to coordinate freelancers or juggle feedback loops.
Each Creative Director has 10+ years of experience, and clients are matched within 72 hours.
Supported by strategists and project managers, this fully managed structure delivers consistent leadership and creative direction that is actually dedicated to your brand.
{{cd-pooyan}}
4. Client Onboarding Process
Before the work starts, onboarding sets the tone, and sometimes the mood.
Here’s how each platform onboards their clients:
A. MarketerHire
To get started, you’ll need to book an appointment with their Growth Marketer so they can better understand your needs, timeline, and budget.
They’ll then match you with a freelancer in about 48 hours after signing up.
Sure, the process seems quick and painless. But if you’re matched with the wrong freelancer, the pain adds up pretty quickly.
B. Designity
Designity’s onboarding feels more like a true partnership. First, you go through a demo call with one of our Account Executives to define your brand, goals, culture, and needs.
Then we’ll hand-match you with a Creative Director who fits your style and objective.
You’re off to the races fast, most teams begin their first project within about 72 hours, but with strategy and creative leadership baked in from day one.
5. Creatives' Vetting Process
Every platform claims they only hire the best. The real question is how they decide who “the best” actually is:
A. MarketerHire
MarketerHire uses a 5-step, AI-powered screening process that rejects about 99% of applicants, combining data from 30,000+ successful matches with human review and real-world performance tracking.
It’s designed to get you a strong individual marketer, fast.
Just keep in mind: once you’re matched, that marketer is your responsibility.
Great hire? Amazing.
Slight mismatch? You’ll know instantly.
B. Designity
Designity’s vetting process is built to select the top 3% of creative talent through a thorough, multi-step evaluation.
Here’s a breakdown:
- Multi-step application: Candidates complete an initial review, a Q&A video call, and a live challenge project to assess real skills and originality.
- Selective acceptance: Only the top 3% of the 1,000+ applicants we receive per week make it into the community.
- Advanced scoring system: Creatives are ranked (emerging, senior, pro) and can level up or down based on performance and client feedback.
- Ongoing development: Workshops, learning sessions, and challenges keep skills sharp and standards high.
And it doesn’t stop there.
Even within the top 3%, your Creative Director hand-picks the right creatives for your specific project and industry, so you’re not just getting talent, you’re getting the right talent.
6. Project Requests and Revisions
Here’s how each platform handles project requests, feedback, and revisions day to day:
A. MarketerHire
With MarketerHire, project requests and revisions happen directly between you and your hired marketer.
There’s no centralized request system, so how work is submitted, tracked, and revised depends on the individual you’re working with.
You decide how you want to communicate: Slack, email, Notion, carrier pigeon, but your freelancer decides when they reply.
Sometimes it’s fast. Sometimes you’ll feel like…
Revisions aren’t unlimited by default and are usually scoped based on whatever you and your marketer agree to upfront.
It’s flexible, but very hands-on, and project momentum lives and dies by how closely you manage it.
B. Designity
At Designity, you submit everything through the Designity Client Portal, including goals, details, and inspiration, so nothing gets lost in Slack threads or email chains.
From there, your Creative Director takes over, hand-selecting the right creatives for the job and managing execution end to end.
You can track progress on Slack, shared Miro boards, Loom updates, and weekly check-ins, so you’re never guessing what’s happening.
And yes, unlike MarketerHire, every Designity plan includes unlimited project requests and unlimited revisions.
Even better, AI-enhanced workflows help reduce revision cycles by up to 60%, meaning less back-and-forth and faster results.
7. Trial Period & Pricing Plans
Here’s how MarketerHire and Designity stack up when it comes to trial periods, costs, and value for money:
A. MarketerHire
MarketerHire pricing is role-based, meaning what you pay depends on the level and scope of the marketer you hire.
Here’s how it generally breaks down:
- Starter: $5,000+/month
- One junior or mid-level marketer
- Single-channel focus (paid social, SEO, email, etc.)
- Tactical execution over strategy
- Best for testing a channel or hiring your first marketer
- Growth: $10,000+/month
- More experienced, multi-channel marketer
- Strategic implementation and performance optimization
- Handles moderate scope and complexity
- Scale: $15,000+/month
- Senior leadership roles like fractional CMO or creative strategist
- Cross-channel planning and executive-level guidance
Psst… for $5,995/month, Designity gives you a full-stack creative and marketing team, led by a dedicated Creative Director.
Now, back to MarketerHire.
They do also offer a two-week trial period so you can validate the fit. If it’s not working out, you can rematch with another marketer at no additional cost.
A few things to keep in mind:
- You’re hiring individual roles, not a team
- Creative direction, prioritization, and quality control stay with you
- Design and creative execution may require additional hires
B. Designity
Before we talk pricing, one thing to know: Designity also offers a two-week trial.
You can test our quality, speed, and communication across all 100+ creative and marketing services, risk-free.
If it’s not a fit, cancel within 14 days. No charge. No awkward breakup.
Now, pricing.
Designity keeps things simple with flexible month-to-month plans, not role-based pricing.
The Plus plan starts at $5,995/month and includes:
- A dedicated Creative Director
- 120 creative hours
- 24-hour turnaround on minor tasks
- Unlimited requests and revisions
- Access to all services
Need more output?
The Premium plan starts at $8,995/month for more creative hours per month, more projects, and faster turnaround times.
Prefer something a little more custom?
Mix and match with a Custom plan that scales as you grow.
You can also switch to quarterly or annual billing anytime, saving you $1,500 per quarter or $10,800 per year.
The Final Match: Managed Team or Marketing Musical Chairs?
At the end of the day, the choice between MarketerHire and Designity comes down to how you want to work.
If you’re looking for a specific marketer to plug into an existing system and you’re comfortable managing direction, timelines, and quality yourself, MarketerHire can be a solid option.
Designity, on the other hand, is built for teams that want to move faster without adding more to their plate.
With fully managed creative and marketing services, a dedicated Creative Director, and the ability to scale output without hiring or juggling freelancers, Designity removes friction from execution and keeps work consistent as you grow.
Both platforms solve real problems.
The difference is whether you want to find talent or get work done.
If you’re leaning toward the latter, Designity is definitely the better long-term creative partner.
And with a two-week trial and no upfront commitment, you can see the difference for yourself before deciding.
FAQs
Here are the answers to a few burning questions related to MarketerHire vs Designity:
1. What Is the Difference between Designity and MarketerHire?
The core difference is the service model.
MarketerHire connects you with individual freelance marketers, while Designity provides a fully managed Creative-as-a-Service (CaaS) team.
With MarketerHire, you’re responsible for direction, timelines, quality control, and coordination once you’re matched.
With Designity, every project is led by a dedicated Creative Director who manages strategy, execution, and a handpicked creative team, so your team focuses on outcomes, not managing people.
2. Why Should I Choose Designity Over MarketerHire?
Choose Designity if you want work done, not just talent sourced.
Designity is built for teams that:
- Don’t want to manage freelancers day to day
- Need consistent quality across multiple projects and channels
- Want senior creative oversight included, not upsold
- Need flexibility to scale without hiring
Instead of relying on one freelancer’s skill set, availability, and communication style, Designity gives you a managed team, unlimited requests and revisions, and a Creative Director who keeps everything aligned and moving.
3. What Project Types Does Designity Offer that MarketerHire Does Not?
MarketerHire is role-based and typically focused on single-channel marketing execution (paid media, SEO, email, etc.).
Designity offers 100+ creative and marketing services, including:
- Brand identity and visual systems
- Web and landing page design and development
- Motion graphics, video, and animation
- UX/UI and product design
- Sales decks, pitch decks, and event assets
- Marketing audits and strategy
With a Creative Director and the right specialists assigned to each project, Designity removes the risk of being limited by a single freelancer’s skill set when priorities shift.
4. Is Designity More Cost-Effective than MarketerHire?
For most teams, yes, especially at scale.
MarketerHire starts around $5,000/month for one junior or mid-level marketer focused on a single channel. Senior strategy roles often cost $10,000–$15,000/month.
Designity starts at $5,995/month and includes:
- A full-stack creative and marketing team
- A dedicated Creative Director
- Unlimited requests and revisions
- Access to all 100+ services
Instead of paying more for individual roles and managing them yourself, Designity delivers broader coverage, built-in leadership, faster turnaround, and lower management overhead, often at a lower total cost.
5. Is Designity a Good Alternative to MarketerHire?
Yes. Designity is a strong alternative to MarketerHire, especially for teams that need fully managed creative and marketing support rather than a single freelancer.
Where MarketerHire connects you with individual marketing talent that you must manage, Designity provides:
- A dedicated Creative Director with 10+ years of experience
- A team of marketing and creative specialists matched to your needs
- 100+ creative and marketing services on every plan
- Unlimited requests and revisions on all plans
- Predictable monthly plans instead of role-based billing
Designity is especially valuable if you want consistent quality across projects, less internal management, and creative output that scales without hiring or juggling freelancers.
For teams focused on getting work done and moving fast with strategic oversight, Designity is an excellent long-term alternative to MarketerHire.
Keep Exploring:
- While you’re here, check out how we compare to Superside and Design Pickle.
- And if PeoplePerHour is on your shortlist, don’t miss our comparison with Designity.
