If you’re comparing Superside vs Designity, you’re likely trying to answer one very real question:
Which one actually makes my creative life easier?
With so many platforms offering similar services, the differences can start to feel like fine print.
And we get it.
You want great work, flexible plans, and a creative partner who gets your brand without all the back-and-forth.
So in this comparison, we’ll break down the real differences between Superside and Designity, including their quality of service, how many services they offer, how flexible their pricing plans are, and more.
What Is Superside?
Superside is a Palo Alto–based subscription design service that connects brands with a global network of designers.
Instead of hiring freelancers one by one, you get ongoing access to a creative team through an annual subscription.
Yep, a whole damn year. Once you’re in, you’re really in (whether you like it or not).
And you don’t even get dedicated creative directors, but rather project managers who will try their best to keep everything organized and moving forward.
When it comes to clients, Superside tends to work with larger enterprise brands but they do take on mid-size clients, too.
For example, they’ve worked with brands like Booking.com, Lyft, Reddit and Shopify.
What Is Designity?
Based in New York, Designity is a Creative-as-a-Service platform built to give brands a smarter, more flexible alternative to agencies.
You get on-demand access to the top 3% of US-based creatives across branding, UX/UI, web design, development, and more.
And the best part?
Everything is led by your dedicated Creative Director (your main point of contact) with 10+ years of experience, keeping your vision consistent and your projects on track.
Designity has partnered with standout brands like Marriott, Calendly, and Kung Fu Tea, helping teams of different sizes scale creative output without the growing pains.
A Comparison at First Glance: Superside vs Designity
While these two companies may sound very similar, there are some key differences in how they operate and engage with clients.
Now, let’s take a closer look at how these two creative platforms differ in terms of:
- Quality of Service
- Range of Services
- Creative Director Supervision
- Location of Creatives
- Creatives Vetting Process
- Project Requests and Revisions
- Pricing Plan Options
1. Quality of Service
When it comes to creative partnerships, the real story is told by the people who’ve actually worked with them.
Here’s how each company stacks up when it comes to quality, client satisfaction, and the overall experience they deliver:
A. Superside
Superside holds a 3.7/5 rating on Trustpilot, which… isn’t exactly confidence-boosting.
Think of it like choosing a restaurant: nobody gets excited about a 3.7 when there are plenty of 4.5+ options nearby (or 4.9 if you go with Designity).
A creative partner should inspire trust, consistency, and quality, and a rating like this suggests clients aren’t always getting the experience or quality of results they hoped for.
B. Designity
Designity comes in strong with a 4.9/5 Trustpilot rating, which speaks for itself.
Our clients consistently highlight the quality of the work, reliable communication, and an overall experience that actually feels supportive.
A near-perfect score doesn’t happen by accident; it’s the result of delivering great creative services, fast turnaround times, and keeping clients genuinely satisfied from project kickoff to final delivery.
2. Range of Services
Now, let’s compare the services each platform delivers, and how far they go:
A. Superside
Superside only offers around 20 design services (based on available dollars in monthly subscription) spanning ad design, social content, motion graphics, immersive design, email creation, and more.
If it needs designing, animating, polishing, or producing, they probably have a specialist for it.
But if you need holistic marketing services?
You can kiss them goodbye.
B. Designity
Designity goes beyond high-quality design and offers 100+ creative and marketing services across all plans (Just a tad more than Superside’s… um, what, 20?).
We cover everything from social ads, UX/UI, and web development to email campaigns, SEO, video production, content creation, packaging, and more.
It’s built for teams that want strategy and execution without juggling multiple vendors.
Everything runs through your dedicated Creative Director, ensuring the work stays aligned, on-brand, and thoughtfully led.
Plus, you can instantly add more creatives to your plan if you need to scale up your marketing efforts.
3. Creative Director Supervision
Creative Director (CD) supervision keeps your projects aligned, on-brand, and moving in the right direction. Let’s compare how Superside and Designity handle it:
A. Superside
Instead of collaborating directly with a hands-on Creative Director, you’re supported by Project Managers and Customer Success Managers who do what they can do (definitely not what a Creative Director does).
Just watch out for longer feedback loops, brand inconsistencies, and a noticeable lack of strategic direction. (BTW, you definitely DON’T want that).
Quick side note: while Superside does have Creative Directors, their focus is largely internal, building systems, maintaining quality frameworks, and shaping operations rather than guiding individual client creative direction.
In other words, their Creative Directors ARE NOT DEDICATED to you!
And if you’re curious about timing, Superside notes that most clients go from contract start to submitting their first project in about 7.6 days.
B. Designity
At Designity, every client gets a dedicated Creative Director, regardless of the plan.
This isn’t just timeline management; your CD is a hands-on creative partner who helps shape ideas, refine direction, and keep everything aligned through weekly calls and ongoing communication.
They also manage and brief your creative team members, so you never have to juggle freelancers or coordinate tasks.
Each Creative Director has 10+ years of experience, and Designity hand-matches you with the right one in about 72 hours.
Supported by strategists and project managers, this structure gives you consistent leadership, strong creative direction, and a truly collaborative experience.
If you’re even still wondering who to side with: it’s not Superside.
They belong on the side lines.
4. Location of Creatives
The people behind the pixels matter. Here’s how each platform builds its creative team:
A. Superside
Superside has a global team of animators, project managers, AI specialists, and more.
What this means for you:
- You get access to a global pool of talent, not just one local team (watch out for language barriers and timezone issues!)
- Many creatives come from top agencies and big brands, so the work is polished and fast.
- Because the model is built for high volume, your main point of contact is usually a project manager, not a single dedicated Creative Director.
- Global timezone coverage, but like we said, you may occasionally run into timezone quirks or communication gaps.
In short: Superside is great if you need a lot of output quickly. But if you prefer long-term creative continuity with the same designer or creative lead, you’ll want to ask how they handle consistency upfront or just work with Designity instead (more on why below).
B. Designity
Designity’s entire creative network, including Creative Directors, is US-based, spread across all US time zones.
That’s intentional.
Keeping teams stateside means you’re working in similar business hours, so feedback loops are faster, weekly video calls are easy to schedule, and last-minute tweaks don’t slip overnight.
Bonus perks:
- Less timezone ping-pong: real-time collaboration, fewer delays.
- Shared context: US market nuances, seasons, and standards.
- Security & compliance: US contracts, NDAs, and data practices.
- Scalable coverage: East–West time zones let work progress all day.
5. Creatives Vetting Process
Here’s how each platform finds, tests, and selects the creatives who’ll be tackling your projects:
A. Superside
Superside’s creatives are mostly full-time employees, with freelancers used only in rare cases.
Their vetting process is structured and multi-step:
- An initial screening
- A creative assessment (3–5 days)
- Reviews with senior creative leaders
- Final interviews with reference checks
For Creative Directors and Associate Creative Directors, the process includes an in-depth case
study.
B. Designity
Designity’s vetting process is built to identify the top 3% of US-based creative talent through a thorough, multi-step evaluation. Here’s how it works:
- Multi-step application: Candidates complete an initial review, a Q&A video call, and a live challenge project to assess real skills and originality.
- Selective acceptance: With 1,000+ applicants per week, only the top 3% make it into the community.
- Advanced scoring system: Creatives are ranked (emerging, senior, pro) and can level up or down based on performance and client feedback.
- Ongoing development: Workshops, learning sessions, and challenges keep skills sharp and standards high.
This rigorous process ensures consistently high-caliber talent and makes Designity one of the best Superside alternatives.
Oh and don't worry, we don’t ever let you work with freelancers.
6. Project Requests and Revisions
How easy is it to submit project requests and get revisions without chaos?
Let’s find out:
A. Superside
To submit a project, you’ll need to upload your brief into their platform, and your Project Manager reviews it to confirm next steps.
You can track progress, share feedback, and access deliverables all in one place (or integrate with Asana, Slack, and more).
Every project includes only two rounds of revisions and goes through internal quality checks to keep things aligned, consistent, and moving.
B. Designity
To submit a project request, just log into the Designity Client Portal and outline your goals, details, and inspiration, everything in one place for clear direction from day one.
Once submitted, your Creative Director takes over, hand-selecting the ideal creatives from our US-based talent pool to ensure the right expertise, style, and experience for your project.
You can track progress through shared Miro boards, Loom updates, and weekly check-ins, so you always know exactly where things stand.
And unlike Superside who throws in the towel after two rounds of revisions, every one of Designity’s plans includes unlimited project requests AND unlimited revisions.
But it doesn’t end there.
Thanks to our AI-enhanced workflows, our team can reduce revision cycles by up to 60%, so you get faster progress with far less back-and-forth.
7. Pricing Plan Options
Here’s how Superside and Designity stack up when it comes to cost, flexibility, and overall value:
A. Superside
Superside’s pricing is, well… super hard to find.
Their pricing page barely tells you anything (not even a number), so you’ll have to hop on a call just to figure out what you might actually be paying.
What we could dig up is that they lock you into one-year contracts MINIMUM.
And to make matters worse, there’s no trial, so you’re basically expected to dive headfirst into a year-long commitment without ever testing the waters.
According to their site, every plan includes:
- All creative subscription services (based on budget)
- Global timezone coverage
- AI-enhanced workflows
- Full access to the Superspace platform
- And more
And just so you’re not surprised later, there’s also a $1,000 monthly service fee for tools, platform updates, and integrations. And that’s on top of whatever plan you’re already paying for.
B. Designity
Before we dive into our pricing, you should know that we also offer a two-week trial so you can experience our quality, speed, and communication with zero risk.
You can test-drive all our 100+ creative and marketing services during this period. If we’re not the one, you can cancel within 14 days with no charge (no awkward breakups here).
Now, back to pricing.
At Designity, we keep things simple with flexible month-to-month plans that are crystal clear on our pricing page.
Our most affordable tier (Plus plan) starts at $5,995/month (monthly billing cycle). Under this plan you get a ton of cool stuff like:
- A dedicated creative director
- 120 creative hours/month
- 24-hour turnaround on minor tasks
- Unlimited requests, revisions, and storage
- Access to 100+ creative and marketing services
- And more
We also have a Premium plan that starts at $8,995/month (monthly billing cycle) where you get all the above but just a whole lot more of it!
Want a plan that actually fits you?
That’s where our Custom plan comes in. You can mix and match what you need and scale it up whenever you’re ready!
And if monthly billing isn’t your vibe, no worries; we’re flexible on that, too! You can switch to quarterly or annual billing any time.
In fact, choosing quarterly saves you $1,500 every three months, and going annual puts $10,800 a year back in your pocket.
Ding! Ding! Ding! Designity Wins (Clearly)
Choosing the right creative partner comes down to what you actually value.
Sure, Superside delivers a sleek, tech-driven setup and fast-moving execution.
But if you want:
- Flexible and transparent month-to-month plans
- A dedicated Creative Director
- 100+ creative and marketing services
- Top 3% US talent
- Unlimited revisions in every plan
- Faster turnaround times
Then, Designity offers a more personalized and strategic experience.
Plus, we offer a 2 week trial (no upfront payment).
Book a demo call today and discover why Designity is one of the best Superside competitors.
Keep Exploring:
- While you’re here, explore 10 of the best full-service marketing agencies out there.
- And if PeoplePerHour is on your shortlist, don’t miss our comparison with Designity.
